How to Handle IRS Notices for Years You Don't Remember Filing
You receive an IRS notice about a tax year from several years ago. You don't remember what you filed. You have no records. This guide explains how to verify what the IRS shows and determine your obligations.
Why the IRS contacts you about old years
The IRS maintains permanent records of tax obligations. Notices about old years typically indicate:
- Unfiled returns — The IRS identified income reported to them but no corresponding return filed by you
- Unresolved balances — A balance due was assessed but never paid or resolved
- Prior notice escalation — Earlier notices were sent but not responded to, triggering continued collection
- Collection activity resumption — The IRS is actively collecting on an old debt
- Substitute for Return (SFR) — The IRS filed a return on your behalf and assessed tax
The IRS does not forget about tax obligations. Issues from years ago can resurface at any time within the collection statute.
How the IRS tracks your filing history
The IRS maintains records for each taxpayer identification number (SSN or EIN):
- Income reported — All W-2s, 1099s, and other information returns filed by third parties
- Returns filed — Each return received, with filing date and amounts reported
- Assessments made — Tax, penalties, and interest assessed for each period
- Payments applied — All payments received and how they were credited
- Notices sent — Record of all correspondence
- Current balance — Amount owed for each tax period
Even if you have no records, the IRS has a complete history of what they received and what they show you owe.
Your memory vs IRS records
You may not remember whether you filed a return 8 years ago. The IRS knows exactly what they received. A compliance review retrieves your IRS records to show what the IRS has documented for each year in question.
Reconstructing your tax history
If you don't have personal records, IRS transcripts provide the information you need:
- Account Transcript — Shows whether a return was filed, any balance assessed, payments made, and current status for each year
- Wage and Income Transcript — Shows all income reported to the IRS by employers and payers for each year
- Tax Return Transcript — Shows line-by-line data from returns you filed (if any)
- Record of Account — Combines account transcript with return information
Availability: Transcripts are generally available online for the most recent 10 tax years. For older years, you may need to request by mail (Form 4506-T) or contact the IRS directly.
The 10-year collection statute
The IRS generally has 10 years from the date of assessment to collect a tax debt. This is called the Collection Statute Expiration Date (CSED).
Key points:
- The 10 years begins when tax is assessed, not when the return was due or filed
- Each tax year has its own CSED
- After the CSED, the IRS cannot legally collect the debt
Events that extend or suspend the CSED:
- Bankruptcy filing
- Offer in Compromise submission
- Collection Due Process hearing request
- Installment Agreement request (sometimes)
- Time spent living outside the US
- Time the IRS is legally prohibited from collecting
A debt you thought was expired may still be collectible if any of these events occurred.
What if you don't remember filing?
If the IRS shows a return was filed: The IRS has your return on record. You can request a Tax Return Transcript to see what was reported. You may have filed and forgotten, or someone (tax preparer, spouse) may have filed on your behalf.
If the IRS shows no return filed: Either you didn't file, or the IRS didn't receive/process your return. If you believe you filed:
- Look for IRS acknowledgment letters or e-file confirmations
- Check for certified mail receipts
- Contact any tax preparer you may have used
- Check bank records for refund deposits or payment debits
If you cannot prove filing and the IRS shows no return, you are treated as a non-filer for that year.
What if you did file but can't prove it?
Without proof of filing, your assertion that you filed is not sufficient. The IRS will continue treating the year as unfiled.
Options:
- File a return now — Even if you believe you filed before, submitting a return resolves the unfiled status. You can note "duplicate if previously filed" but the IRS will process the return you submit.
- Request IRS research — The IRS can sometimes locate returns that were misfiled or not properly processed. This requires contacting the IRS directly.
Resolving old year compliance issues
For unfiled years:
- The IRS typically requires filing the last 6 years of unfiled returns to be considered compliant
- Older years may not need to be filed unless the IRS specifically requests them
- If the IRS filed an SFR, you can file an original return to potentially reduce the assessed amount
For old balances:
- Check if the CSED has passed (the debt may be legally uncollectible)
- If still within CSED, payment options include full payment, installment agreement, or offer in compromise
- Currently Not Collectible status may be available if you cannot pay
Examples of old year situations
Example 1: Forgotten balance from a decade ago
Situation:
Taxpayer receives CP504 for tax year 2016 showing $8,000 owed. They don't remember this debt and have no records from that year. They assumed old debts would go away.
Analysis:
Account transcript shows return filed in 2017, balance assessed April 2017. CSED is April 2027. The debt is still collectible. Taxpayer must address the balance through payment, arrangement, or hardship status.
Example 2: SFR from years ago
Situation:
Taxpayer receives a levy notice for 2019. They don't recall receiving earlier notices. Account transcript shows the IRS filed an SFR in 2021 assessing $15,000. Taxpayer actually owed much less based on actual deductions and credits.
Analysis:
Taxpayer can file an original return for 2019 to replace the SFR. If the actual tax liability is lower, the assessment will be reduced. However, penalties for failure to file still apply, and any refund opportunity for that year has likely expired.
Example 3: Expired debt
Situation:
Taxpayer receives a notice showing they owe $5,000 for 2012. They filed and never paid. No bankruptcy, no offers submitted, no payment agreements. Assessment was made in April 2013.
Analysis:
CSED was April 2023. If no extending events occurred, the debt is now legally uncollectible. Taxpayer should verify CSED with IRS and request the debt be marked as expired. The IRS should not be collecting on this debt.
Key insight:
Your memory and records may be incomplete, but IRS records are comprehensive. Resolving old year issues requires understanding what the IRS actually shows—not what you remember. Account transcripts provide the factual basis for determining what obligations exist and what options are available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Request a Compliance Review
This guide explains how to handle notices for old tax years. A compliance review retrieves and analyzes your IRS records across all years to determine what the IRS shows and what obligations exist.
Request a Compliance Review